Between mutual respect and questioning | MageP's Lab

Between mutual respect and questioning

Tuesday, May 29th, 2007 | 9:36 am @ SK

As Malaysia is moving towards 50 years of nationhood, I can safely conclude that Information Minister Zainuddin Maidin is a minister who is lacking of ministerial material (some say, void of quality at all!) proven through statements he made for the past few months.

Being an Information Minister, he is clueless on what’s blogging all about. His statements with regarding to Malaysia blogging community is inconsistent too by trying his luck through various measures, either through intimidation or even suggestion to classify bloggers into professional and non-professional bloggers.

Now, he is on a new headline, asking Malaysians especially students studying oversea to foster unity and show mutual respect to each other but not questioning what has become a social contract in this country.

Being the chosen ones, he said the students must be mindful of each others’ sensitivities and not raise questions on matters that have been ingeniously agreed to by the country’s forefathers nearly 50 years ago.

"Matters like how the Chinese and Indians can become Malaysian citizens, why only the Malays can become rulers, why Islam became the official religion and why Bahasa Malaysia is the national language should not be questioned anymore,"

Mutual respect is one thing, however it’s not right at all to conclude that questioning equals not showing respect. Critical thinkers are what this country need and we should encourage intellectual discourse among students instead of accepting what’s being taught wholeheartedly.

Students too, as part of this country, have the right to understand what’s social contract is all about and why its formulation at first place. How can the Information Minister denies students the right to information?


5 Responses to “Between mutual respect and questioning”

  1. nazlihaffiz says:

    not only him.. quite a few are lacking the ministerial qualities..

  2. nicktay says:

    Agreed. Some things decided back in 1957 when Malaysia was formed may not be right for Malaysia in 2007 and moving forward. Questioning and improving is the only way forward.

  3. kittykat46 says:

    Of course these things need to be questioned. If you are confident with the  answers, you should not be afraid of the questions.
    Has Zam never heard of intellectual discourse ? Why does he always think that raising questions on constitutional matters will lead to violence, riots etc. 
    The nation needs to avoid being stuck in 1969.
    Frankly Zam has long passed his shelf-life as a Minister. Time to retire.

  4. bayi says:

    I see him as a court jester (but the there are so many in our Cabinet!), keen to apple-polish to keep his job despite not knowing what he’s been babbling about!

    Very, very tragic for our country to have “leaders” like him.

  5. bayi says:

    Perhaps he should be the Dis-information Minister!

Leave a Reply